A classic dish...& what a gem! The thing about fish pie is that, unlike similar sorts of dishes like lasagne & shepherd's pie, it has an element of luxury & decadence but is just as simple if not simpler to cook. We've made a few little tweaks to personalise this one & you should feel free to do so yourself. You can use any firm fleshed fish in this, but if you're particularly wealthy or its a special occasion you can add cream, saffron, monkfish, prawns or even lobster to the sauce. But
please use sustainably sourced fish if you can get it!
Ingredients
- 250g each of salmon, smoked haddock and whiting
- 400ml milk
- a thick slice of onion
- 2 cloves
- 2 bay leaves
- 4 large baking potatoes & 1/2 medium celeriac chopped into cubes (we don't bother to peel the potatoes because they are the most nutritious bit...also we're lazy, but you can if you want to)
- 50-100g of mature cheddar grated
- 50g butter
- dessertspoon of plain flour
- 1 large leek thickly sliced
- white pepper
- salt
- juice of 1/4 lemon
- some chopped dill & parsley (about 2 parts parsley to 1 part dill)
- small handful of breadcrumbs (optional)
Preparation
- Lay the fish in a large, deep, frying
pan. Cover with the milk and add the cloves, bay leaves and onion. Bring to a gentle boil, simmer for a minute or two then turn the heat off & cover the pan with a lid or a plate & let it gently poach in the residual heat for 10 minutes.
- Meanwhile, steam or boil the potatoes & celeriac in salted water. When they are cooked through, (very important, you don't want lumpy mash!) add half the butter & a splash of milk & mash until smooth. Add most of the grated cheese & white pepper to taste & mix in until the cheese is melted.
- Once the fish it only just cooked, drain off the milk (which is now flavoured with all the fishy loveliness) into a jug to be used in the sauce. Flake the fish into large pieces & carefully lay them on the bottom of a baking dish, trying to get the different pieces of fish equally distributed.
- Melt the other half of the butter in another frying pan & saute the leeks until just soft. Take off the heat & add the flour, stirring constantly. Put back on the heat & gradually add the milky fish liquor, stirring constantly until the sauce comes up to the boil & has thickened. Turn the heat down very low & cook out for a few minutes to remove any floury taste & give the sauce a velvety quality. Once cooked, add the herbs, a pinch of white pepper & lemon juice.
- Pour the sauce over the fish & give it a very gentle mix in. Most people mix the fish into the sauce, then pour it all into the baking dish, but this way you keep the big pieces of fish & its easier to make sure the fish is evenly distributed across the dish. At this point it is actually a good idea to let everything cool down if you have time because the potato will spread more easily, but its not essential.
- Spread the mash over the fish, starting from the edges of the dish & working inwards, this should stop the potato sliding over the sauce & everything getting messy. Sprinkle over the remaining cheese & the breadcrumbs if you're using them. (
Tip: Whenever we buy a nice loaf of bread, there's always an end piece that ends up being too stale to use, instead of throwing it away we blitz it up & keep it in a sealed jar in the kitchen cupboard, its amazing how often it comes in handy!) You can also add a few small knobs of butter at this point if you like, it'll really help the 'engoldening' process.
- Put on a preheated oven at 180C for about 40-45mins until it is heated through & the top is golden & crunchy.